Gareth Cliff argues that the DA should let its rivals govern Gauteng’s contested metros and answer for the consequences. The electoral logic is clear. The public interest demands a harder test.
The Democratic Alliance emerged as the largest party in Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni, yet that lead has not settled who will govern. In all three, the election has left parties negotiating the support needed to take office. The declared results distinguish an electoral lead from an outright majority.
For Gareth Cliff, this presents an opportunity. His argument is that the DA should leave the coalition negotiations, allow the ANC, ActionSA and their partners to take responsibility, and become a relentless opposition. If services fail to improve, those governing should face the electoral consequences.
It is an intelligible political strategy. Its weakness is the interval between a party escaping responsibility and a city recovering from another period of poor government. Residents have to live through that interval.

A lead does not confer the mayor’s office
Cliff’s case rests partly on the contention that the DA has already won. That needs precision. Being the largest party gives it a strong negotiating position and a substantial constituency to represent. It does not automatically entitle it to govern alone.
South Africa’s municipal system places authority in elected councils. Under section 55 and Schedule 3 of the Municipal Structures Act, councillors elect an executive mayor from among their members. The mayoral election is a separate institutional step from the public vote. Parties with fewer seats can therefore assemble the support to elect a mayor even when the largest party opposes them.
Such an arrangement can be politically disappointing to the largest party’s supporters without being an evasion of democracy. The proper questions are whether it commands the necessary council support, respects the law and produces accountable government.
Nor should negotiations be confused with a completed administration. On 18 November, Eyewitness News reported that the ANC had postponed a briefing because coalition talks were continuing. Its reporting that morning described an ANC offer giving ActionSA the Johannesburg and Tshwane mayoralties, with the ANC retaining Ekurhuleni, and said agreements had not yet been reached at that stage. DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis said his party was unlikely to match that offer.
The distinction matters. An offer describes what parties want. A council vote determines who takes office. Neither proves that services will improve.
What the audit evidence supports
Cliff’s scepticism about municipal government has a substantial evidential foundation. In its 2024/25 findings, the Auditor-General reported only 39 clean audits, representing 15% of municipalities. The institution also reported deteriorating metro outcomes. These are findings about public administration, rather than predictions about a particular coalition.
The record also challenges the certainty that nothing can change. Compared with 2020/21, 72 municipalities improved their audit outcomes, 145 remained unchanged and 38 regressed. Two audits were outstanding at the report’s cut-off. Improvement exists alongside widespread weakness.
Audit outcomes measure financial reporting, performance reporting and compliance. They should inform a judgment about government, but they cannot alone establish whether every neighbourhood receives reliable water or refuse collection. Equally, national findings cannot establish that an unformed ANC and ActionSA administration is certain to fail.
Cliff’s forecast belongs in the realm of political judgment. The evidence warrants demanding safeguards and measurable results from any incoming government. It cannot settle those results in advance.
The strongest case against walking away
There is a practical argument for opposition: a party may be more useful exposing failures than lending its name to an arrangement it cannot influence. Office without the ability to govern can leave voters unable to identify who is responsible.
The strongest counterargument is that negotiation is itself part of the mandate in a divided council. A party elected on promises of repair should test whether a workable agreement can deliver them. Walking away may protect its reputation while surrendering an opportunity to improve administration.
Helen Zille has articulated a different strategic approach. Earlier in the talks, she identified ActionSA or the ANC as her preferred Johannesburg coalition partners, arguing that fewer partners would make an administration easier to manage. That does not establish that either partnership would succeed. It does show why the choice deserves more scrutiny than a simple instruction to withdraw.
The public-interest test should be concrete. Can the parties agree on a funded programme, responsibilities for delivery, professional administration and a credible way to resolve disputes? Will they publish enough information for residents to judge performance? Those are reasonable demands of a proposed government, whatever its composition.
Residents cannot all buy their way out
Cliff also urges people to become as independent of government as possible. As household advice, contingency planning may be sensible. As a civic answer, it is incomplete: private alternatives depend on money, and households remain part of a shared city.
The constitutional obligation endures. Section 152 requires municipalities to pursue sustainable services and accountable local government; section 153 gives priority to communities’ basic needs in administration, budgeting and planning.
The DA may ultimately judge that opposition is its most responsible position. ANC and ActionSA negotiators may argue that their arrangement offers a workable alternative. Neither proposition deserves acceptance on its own terms. Both must be judged against what residents receive, what the municipality can afford and who can be held answerable when commitments are missed.
A coalition exit could give the DA a useful story at the next election. Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni need a programme that works before then.