The ANC’s decline has opened the contest for municipal power. The harder question is whether the parties can turn a council agreement into reliable government.
South Africa’s municipal election has delivered a verdict on the African National Congress. It has not delivered a simple instruction about who should govern every city. The ANC received 30.76% of the national municipal vote, according to the results announced on 8 November. Yet the distribution of council seats, and the agreements councillors can sustain, will determine who exercises local power.
That distinction is central to Johannesburg’s political argument. A party can emerge ahead of its rivals and still need their support. A smaller party can help elect a mayor without having persuaded most residents to vote for it. Both outcomes are possible in a representative democracy. Neither tells residents whether the resulting administration will repair a pipe, collect refuse or manage public money competently.
As of 16 November, the bargaining remained open. Eyewitness News reported that the ANC was widening its search for coalition partners, following talks involving several parties. A proposed combination should therefore be treated as a negotiating possibility until the relevant agreements and council decisions establish otherwise.
Coming first is not a direct election as mayor
South Africans do not directly elect their executive mayors. Under section 55 of the Municipal Structures Act, a council elects an executive mayor from among its members. Schedule 3 provides the election procedure: if there is more than one candidate, voting is by secret ballot and the successful candidate needs a majority of the votes. Where necessary, candidates are eliminated through further rounds. An unopposed candidate is declared elected.
There is no automatic entitlement for the largest party’s mayoral candidate. Winning the most support gives that party an important political argument in negotiations. It does not replace the council vote.
The reverse argument also needs care. If a party receives less than half the vote, it does not follow that everyone who voted elsewhere endorsed a common alternative, or rejected that party’s candidate personally. Voters choose among different programmes and interests. Adding their votes together cannot tell us what bargain they would approve after the election.
Coalition legitimacy consequently has two dimensions. The arrangement must comply with the rules, and its participants must explain what they have agreed to do with the authority entrusted to them. Legal eligibility to govern does not settle the political question of whether a particular agreement honours campaign commitments.
A mayoral victory does not guarantee a working government
The next hurdle is more demanding than securing a title. The Constitution’s section 160 reserves budget approval to the council and requires the support of a majority of its members. The same requirement applies to passing by-laws, imposing rates and other taxes, levies and duties, and raising loans. A majority of members must be present before any vote may be taken.
This matters because abstentions, absences and one-off support can help shape a leadership contest without producing dependable support for the work that follows. Parties negotiating over a mayor should also explain how they intend to approve a funded budget, monitor spending and resolve disagreements over priorities.
A smaller coalition may make negotiation simpler. It does not guarantee competent government. Nor does a larger coalition necessarily make failure inevitable. The more useful questions concern what the partners agree on, how they settle disputes and whether administrators can carry out lawful decisions without each political argument becoming an institutional crisis.
The accounts provide a harder test than the campaign
The stakes extend well beyond personalities. The Auditor-General’s 2024/25 local government findings, released on 24 June 2026, recorded clean audits at only 39 municipalities, or 15%. The report described limited progress in governance and service delivery, alongside deteriorating financial health.
There is important evidence against the claim that nothing improves. The same report found that 72 municipalities had improved their audit outcomes since 2020/21. Disclaimed opinions, the category in which auditors cannot obtain sufficient evidence for most financial information, fell from 29 to eight. Timely submission of financial statements reached 98%.
These gains deserve recognition. A clean audit nevertheless answers a different question from whether every household receives dependable services. Financial credibility, lawful spending and useful performance reporting are foundations for accountability; residents must still be able to test what their municipality actually delivers.

What a coalition should put in writing
Government has now offered a practical benchmark. Cooperative Governance Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa’s coalition guidelines, issued on 11 November, encourage written agreements covering shared priorities, political responsibilities, decision-making and dispute resolution. They also emphasise that appointments, procurement and tender awards must remain with the lawful decision-makers.
The guidelines themselves are non-binding guidance. They distinguish political commitments from municipal law and explain that a change of coalition does not itself erase approved plans, budgets or lawful contracts.
For residents, that suggests a concrete standard: an agreement should explain what happens when the partners disagree, as well as what they intend to achieve while they agree. Publishing the agreement, setting measurable service commitments and reporting progress would make the bargain easier to judge.
The ANC’s reduced support creates opportunities for its competitors and pressure for renewal within the party. It does not establish an inevitable result in 2029. Municipal and national elections answer different questions, and future voters retain the right to change their minds.
Johannesburg’s immediate test is more tangible. The parties seeking office should show how their numbers will support a budget, protect professional administration and deliver work residents can verify. The election has redistributed political bargaining power. The purpose of that power remains the provision of public services.