The ANC’s weakened vote has opened a contest for municipal power. Leon warns the DA against accepting office at any price. The law supplies another caution: finishing first does not confer a right to govern.
South Africa’s municipal election has produced a result that is easier to describe than to turn into functioning government. The ANC remains the largest party nationally, with 30.76% of the vote, against the Democratic Alliance’s 24.64%. Neither figure answers the question that matters in a particular city: who can assemble the support to run it?
Former DA leader Tony Leon offers two warnings. One concerns the national consequences if the ANC helps exclude the DA from cities where it leads. The other concerns the danger to the DA itself if it accepts mayoralties through arrangements that cannot sustain effective government.
The second warning is the more useful guide to the negotiations. A party can secure an office and still lack the dependable council support needed to make that office effective. Residents then inherit the distance between a successful political deal and a working municipality.
A rejection without a single successor
Leon reads the election principally as a rejection of the ANC rather than an unqualified endorsement of one replacement. The published results support that distinction: beyond the two largest parties, the MK Party received 9.76%, the EFF 6.22% and ActionSA 5.67%.
These are national aggregates from a municipal election, not shares of seats in the National Assembly. Their political importance is considerable, but they cannot be converted into a parliamentary majority or a forecast of the next general election. Local contests, candidates and turnout all stand between those propositions.
Nor can the preferences of voters for different parties simply be added together and labelled a common mandate. A voter who rejects the ANC may favour the DA, distrust it, or attach greater importance to a local organisation. Negotiators must reconcile those differences rather than assume that opposition to the same party makes them disappear.
That gives smaller parties a legitimate role. It also imposes a responsibility: they should be able to explain what their bargaining achieves for residents beyond the allocation of positions.
First place is a claim, not an entitlement
Leon argues that the DA’s lead in important cities should carry substantial weight in choosing who governs. Politically, there is force in asking why a party that attracts the largest share of support should be passed over. Legally, however, first place and control are different things.
The Municipal Structures Act provides for councils to elect mayors. In a contested election, Schedule 3 provides for a secret ballot, a majority of votes and, where necessary, successive elimination of the lowest-polling candidate. It does not reserve the office for the largest party.
A coalition excluding that party can therefore be lawful. Whether it is convincing, coherent or capable of governing requires a separate judgment. Equally, a coalition led by the largest party can be lawful and still fail residents.
The distinction matters beyond the DA’s interests. A principle presented as a democratic rule must survive application to a rival. Giving first place an automatic entitlement would also privilege the leading party wherever that party happens to be the ANC or another competitor.
[INFOGRAPHIC: images/three-tests.png | alt: Three tests distinguish municipal power: the largest seat bloc, election of a mayor, and majority support from all councillors to approve the budget. | caption: A plurality, a mayoral victory and a budget majority are different tests. The diagram explains South African municipal rules; it does not depict a particular council’s result.]
The budget is the harder test
The most consequential distinction comes after the mayor has been chosen. Under section 160 of the Constitution, a budget requires the supporting vote of a majority of all council members. That is a different threshold from simply winning a contested mayoral ballot.
An abstention that helps one candidate become mayor does not necessarily supply a vote for that mayor’s budget. An agreement that settles the leadership contest may leave the municipality exposed when spending, revenue and priorities come before council.
This is where Leon’s warning against accepting office too readily has substance. The question for a prospective governing party is whether its partners will sustain an administration through difficult decisions. Who will support an affordable maintenance programme? How will disagreements over spending be resolved? What happens when a partner demands a concession the others cannot defend?
These are practical questions for households paying rates and businesses relying on services. A coalition agreement should make responsibility easier to identify. If each partner can blame the others for every difficult decision, residents lose the ability to judge who has delivered and who has obstructed.
The official 2026 transition circular from cooperative governance authorities, National Treasury and SALGA places the handover in precisely this administrative setting: council establishment, delegations, development plans and municipal support measures all need attention. Choosing political office-bearers is one part of the transition.
Municipal bargaining and the national government
Leon’s more dramatic warning is that municipal arrangements directed against the DA could threaten its continued participation in the Government of National Unity. That is a political assessment, not an announced withdrawal or an automatic constitutional consequence.
The ANC’s public statement of 13 November is important counterevidence to any claim that exclusion has already been settled. It authorises engagement with all parties, civic movements and independents where no party has a majority. It also says agreements should contain a common minimum programme and measurable service-delivery targets, with a fuller update promised for 17 November.
That statement does not guarantee an agreement with the DA. It does establish the position against which the ANC’s eventual decisions can be tested. The appropriate question is which arrangements emerge, what commitments they contain and whether the parties honour them.
Local results also do not dissolve the National Assembly. The ordinary early-dissolution route in section 50(1) of the Constitution requires a resolution supported by a majority of its members and that three years have passed since its election. A municipal setback supplies neither condition by itself.
What residents should demand
Leon’s party loyalties are clear. His broader warning deserves a hearing because it asks politicians to consider the cost of power before taking it.
The same test should apply to every coalition. Residents should be able to read its priorities, identify who is responsible, see how progress will be measured and understand how disputes will be handled. Stability has value when it enables accountable government; preserving a failing arrangement merely preserves the failure.
The election has given parties another opportunity to demonstrate that bargaining can produce something useful. The decisive result will be the administration they build, the budgets they pass and the services those budgets sustain.